Israel court has ended draft exemptions to ultra-Orthodox Jews
Items 1-5 ultra-Orthodox Jews gather in front of an Israeli draft office to apply for their exemptions from military service at a recruiting station situated in Kiryat Ono in Israel on March 28th, 2024. REUTERS/Hannah McKay/File Photo
- Summary
- The court ruling creates a an issue for the government of Netanyahu’s premiership. Netanyahu
- The ultra-Orthodox conscription waiver irritated many Israelis
- Overstretched military says it’s in need of more soldiers
JERUSALEM 25 June (Reuters) Israel’s Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday that the state should begin the process of enlisting ultra-Orthodox Jews from seminaries into the army the decree creates new political tensions for the struggling Premier Benjamin Netanyahu.
Netanyahu’s coalition government is based upon two ultra-Orthodox political parties who see the exclusion of conscription as essential to ensuring their citizens are in seminaries of religion and out of a military melting pot which could test their conservative practices.
Leaders of both parties stated that they were dissatisfied with the decision, but did not issue an immediate threats to the government.
However, the idea that the army, supported by the Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, beginning to recruit seminary students create more cracks in Netanyahu’s fragile coalition.
The ultra-Orthodox conscription exemption has become more and more controversial in Israel because its military forces are stretched due to a multi-front battle between Hamas and Hamas in Gaza as well as Hezbollah from Lebanon.
“At the height of a difficult war, the burden of inequality is more than ever acute,” the court’s unanimous decision said.
Israelis are required by law to join the military at until the age of 18 to serve for three years for men as well as two for females. The 21 percent of Israelis who are part of the Arab minority are not exempt but some do have to serve, as well as ultra-Orthodox Jewish students at seminaries have been mostly exempt for years.
The law that governs the exemption of seminary students was repealed in the year 2000, yet the government did not stop allowing students to not serve. It was the Supreme Court ruled that in the absence of a fresh legal foundation for the exemption the state has to draft them.
This further imposes pressure on ultra-Orthodox coalition The ruling also prohibited seminaries from receiving state aid in the event that scholars do not attend classes without delay or exemption.
A new law is being drafted regarding the subject currently being debated in parliament the minister of education Yoav Kisch, a member of Netanyahu’s Likud Party, voiced hope that an agreement can be reached to reach an agreement.
“Not in a civil war, not in a fight that will tear apart Israeli society in the middle of a tough war. It’s possible to do it together,” Kisch declared.
The political expert Gideon Rahat, of the bi-partisan Israel Democracy Institute, said the decision had put more stress on Netanyahu. “He will try to buy time and make every effort to remove this issue from the public agenda,” said Rahat.
EXISTENTIAL
Although the military has stated that it is in urgent need of more soldiers, ultra-Orthodox leaders believe that the exemptions are essential to preserve their customs.
“There’s no judge there who understands the value of Torah study and its contribution to the people of Israel throughout the generations,” said ultra-Orthodox lawmaker Moshe Gafni, who is the head of the strong parliamentarian Finance Committee, referring to the study of the holy texts of Judaism.
Opposition parties have praised the ruling.
“There’s nothing Jewish about dodging military service,” said the opposition lawmaker and former defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman.
For over an entire six-year period, officials from the State been requesting for the Supreme Court for more time to adopt new laws on conscription to settle the problem.
The latest draft bill which is being debated in parliament could solve the issue in the event that a consensus is reached. In the absence of consensus, it has the potential of bringing Netanyahu’s government to the ground.
Gallant The politician, who’s taken on an independent position against Netanyahu on numerous occasion, is seeking an equitable share of the burden. It’s which is a view shared by many other lawmakers from Netanyahu’s Likud party, as well as the bulk people in the other opposition.
The waiver of military for ultra-Orthodox people has caused uproar over the past few months from Israelis discontented that they are taking on the risk of fighting the conflict in Gaza. In the city protesters of the ultra-Orthodox have blocked the roads in protest of “death before conscription”.
The waivers have a wider impact on the economy. The ultra-Orthodox comprise 13 percent of Israel’s 10 million inhabitants, with a number projected to rise to 19% before 2035 thanks their high birth rate.
The conscription waiver keeps a small portion members of the community at seminaries, but keeps them away from employment, limiting the growth of the economy and placing an additional burden for middle class taxpayers.
Find the most up-to-date information and expert analysis of the current state of the global economy through Reuters Econ World. Join us by clicking here.
Reporting by Maayan Lubell and Ari Rabinovitch; Editing by Edmund Blair, Peter Graff and Gareth Jones
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.
